Spotting Unreliable Online Product Reviews

You want to trust a review before you spend money, and that’s hard. Knowing how to spot fake reviews starts with six checks: vague wording, odd names, extreme sentiment, thin review history, stock photos and strange grammar. This guide is…

how to spot fake reviews

You want to trust a review before you spend money, and that’s hard. Knowing how to spot fake reviews starts with six checks: vague wording, odd names, extreme sentiment, thin review history, stock photos and strange grammar.

This guide is part of our wider look at how to choose consumer products, where reviews are one input among several.

Item Value
Consumers who read online reviews before buying Roughly 95% (Brand Rated survey)
FTC final rule on fake reviews released August 14, 2024
Rule effective date October 21 (per a September 2024 legal analysis)
Maximum FTC penalty Up to $51,744 per rule violation
Ways to spot a fake review in the TechTarget guide Six

The figures come from TechTarget’s guide to fake reviews and BCLP’s analysis of the FTC rule. They can change, so check the sources before you rely on them.

Six signs a review may be fake

Almost every shopper checks reviews first: a Brand Rated survey cited by TechTarget found that roughly 95% read them before buying. That makes reviews a target, and AI-generated text is making fakes more convincing.

The same guide offers six checks. No single one proves a review is fake, so treat them as clues that add up.

  1. Word choice. Generic, vague or basic descriptions that say little about the product are a warning sign. Fake reviews may also overuse “I” and “me”.
  2. Reviewer’s name. A generic or overly common name, or a display name made only of letters and numbers, can point to a fake. Many fake reviews use a first name, middle initial and last name, while authentic ones tend to drop the initial or spell it out.
  3. Extreme sentiment. Honest reviewers typically mention what they like and what they don’t. An unnaturally glowing or hostile spin on a product is suspect.
  4. Review history. Where a profile page exists, open it and look for repeated phrases or a pattern of 100% positive (or 100% negative) ratings, as TechTarget advises. A profile with only one review is a red flag when it appears alongside other signs.
  5. Profile picture. No picture at all can be a signal, especially with a generic name. So can a photo that looks too professional, polished or generic, such as a stock image or an AI-generated face.
  6. Grammar and spelling. Several significant errors can indicate a fake profile. Overly formal grammar can also be a signal.

A fake can pass every one of these checks. The aim is to lower your odds of being misled, not to reach certainty.

Reading patterns across many reviews

Individual details matter, but so does the pattern across a whole page. FTC staff guidance, summarised by the law firm FKKS in its November 2024 post, gives an example of a business that hires a third party to generate reviews by handing out free samples.

In that example, the business would likely be on notice that the reviews are fake or false if:

  • reviews appear so quickly after purchase that it is doubtful they reflect real experience with the product;
  • an unusually large number of reviews appear in a very short period of time; or
  • reviews refer to the wrong product.

Shoppers are not held to that legal test, but the same clues are useful when you scan a page of feedback.

Order matters too. According to the same summary, putting five-star reviews at the top of a page is not covered by the rule, but arranging reviews so that negative ones are hard to find could still be deceptive under the FTC Act. Scroll past the first few entries and read the lower-rated ones as well.

Five yellow stars form a diagonal line across a pink and blue background.

What does the FTC rule ban?

The FTC’s final rule on reviews was released on August 14, 2024, and applies to big retailers and independent online stores alike, according to TechTarget. BCLP’s September 2024 analysis says it takes effect on October 21.

The rule covers six kinds of conduct:

  • Fake reviews, including AI-generated reviews, reviews by people without product experience and reviews that misrepresent the product.
  • Bought reviews: businesses cannot offer compensation or an incentive for a review of any sentiment, positive or negative.
  • Undisclosed insider reviews from employees, managers or contractors who do not clearly reveal their connection.
  • Controlled review sites that falsely present themselves as independent.
  • Review suppression, including unfounded legal threats or intimidation aimed at a negative review.
  • Fake social media indicators, such as followers, likes or views from bots and hijacked accounts.

The FTC can impose penalties of up to $51,744 per rule violation, plus consumer redress and conduct restraints, BCLP reports. The Endorsement Guides, released in June 2023, are not independently enforceable, which is the gap the rule closes.

Where the rule stops

The rule targets businesses and their helpers, not ordinary reviewers. In FKKS’s summary of the FTC staff guidance, ordinary consumers are not liable for what they say in reviews, while influencers who lie, creators of fake reviews and enablers such as advertising, public relations and reputation management companies are.

A retailer that neither buys nor writes reviews does not have to investigate them, even when it solicits or aggregates them. Clear signs of purchased reviews can still trigger liability under a “should have known” standard.

For you, that means a store’s review section is not automatically vetted. Your own checks still matter.

A practical checklist before you buy

  1. Read the lower-rated reviews, not only the ones shown first.
  2. Open reviewer profiles where the site allows it and look for repeated phrases or one-sided histories.
  3. Favour reviews with concrete details over general praise.
  4. Watch for bursts of reviews at once, or reviews that describe a different product.
  5. Check the product’s specifications against what reviewers claim.

Reviews work best as one input, so set them beside the criteria covered in how to compare products. If you shop for appliances in the EU, our EU energy label explained page covers a standardised label that does not rely on anonymous opinions.

Frequently asked questions

Are fake reviews against the law?

Show answer

In the US, creating or selling them is prohibited under the FTC’s August 14, 2024 final rule, AI-generated ones included, according to TechTarget. Rules in other countries are not covered by the sources used here.

Does AI make fake reviews harder to catch?

Show answer

TechTarget says AI-generated reviews are an increasingly common problem and grow harder to tell from real ones as AI improves, in its guide. Weigh several signals together rather than trusting grammar alone.

Does a shop have to check every review?

Show answer

No general duty applies, per the November 2024 FKKS summary. A shop that merely displays reviews need not vet them, but one that purchased reviews it knew or should have known were false can be held responsible.

Is a profile with one review fake?

Show answer

Not necessarily. TechTarget treats a single-review profile as a red flag only when it appears with other signs, such as a generic name or a missing photo.

❧